What a criminal appeal is
A criminal appeal asks a higher court to review a conviction or sentence for legal error. The appellate court does not retry the case, hear witnesses, or decide who was telling the truth. Instead, a criminal appeals attorney reviews the trial transcript, the exhibits, and the rulings the judge made, and argues that a legal mistake — a wrongly admitted piece of evidence, an incorrect jury instruction, a constitutional violation — requires the conviction to be reversed or the sentence reduced.
Because the appeal is decided on the written record, the quality of the brief matters more than anything else. The best criminal appeals attorneys are appellate litigators first: researchers and brief writers who know the appellate judges, the standards of review, and the arguments most likely to persuade a panel.
Direct appeal vs. post-conviction relief
A direct appeal is the first challenge to a conviction, filed shortly after sentencing. Post-conviction relief — including habeas corpus petitions — comes later, and is used when the issue could not have been raised on direct appeal, for example because it depends on facts outside the trial record, such as ineffective assistance of counsel or newly discovered evidence. A post-conviction specialist handles both tracks and knows which one fits your case.
The two paths have different deadlines, different courts, and different rules, and choosing the wrong one can waste the one chance you get. If you are unsure which applies, an appellate attorney can review the record and tell you before any deadline passes.
Standards of review in criminal appeals
Not every mistake wins an appeal. Appellate courts review questions of law fresh (de novo), but give deference to a trial judge’s discretionary rulings and to a jury’s findings of fact. Many criminal appeals are lost not because no error occurred, but because the error was not preserved at trial — no objection was made, so the appellate court reviews only for plain error, a much harder standard. This is why experienced appellate counsel reviews the record for preserved issues first.
Deadlines: the clock starts immediately
In most courts the notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days of sentencing or entry of judgment, and the deadline is rarely extended. Federal and state rules differ, and post-trial motions can change the calculation. Do not wait to see whether the sentence can be negotiated down — contact a criminal appeals attorney as soon as the verdict comes in.
What to look for in a criminal appeals attorney
Look for an attorney who handles appeals full time, not a trial lawyer who occasionally files one. Ask how many criminal appeals they have briefed and argued, whether they have published opinions, and who will actually write the brief. Board certification in appellate law, former clerkship or public defender appellate experience, and familiarity with the specific appellate court are strong signals. A good criminal appeals attorney will also give you an honest assessment of your chances before you spend money on a transcript.
Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Appeals Attorney
Usually only on narrow grounds, such as whether the plea was voluntary and knowing, whether the court had jurisdiction, or whether the sentence was illegal. In many jurisdictions you need the trial court’s permission (a certificate of probable cause) before you can appeal a plea at all. An appellate attorney can tell you quickly whether your plea leaves anything to appeal.
A post-conviction specialist is an attorney who focuses on collateral challenges to a conviction after the direct appeal — habeas corpus petitions, motions for a new trial based on new evidence, and claims of ineffective assistance of counsel. These cases turn on facts outside the trial record, so they require investigation as well as briefing.
No. A direct appeal is decided on the trial record alone. New evidence belongs in post-conviction proceedings, such as a habeas petition or a motion for a new trial, where the court can consider facts that were not before the jury.
The usual result is a reversal and a new trial, or a reduced sentence — not an automatic release. The prosecution may retry the case, negotiate a plea, or, in some cases, decline to proceed. Your appellate attorney should explain the realistic outcomes before the appeal is filed.
Find an Appellate Attorney in Your State
Browse certified appellate specialists and appeals lawyers in the states with the largest directories — or view all 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Browse appellate attorneys in all states → · Back to the homepage