What an employment appeal is
An employment appeal asks a higher court to review the outcome of a workplace case — a wrongful termination claim, a discrimination or harassment verdict, a wage-and-hour judgment, or a dismissal of the case — for legal error. Either side can appeal: the employee can challenge a defense verdict, and the employer can challenge a verdict it considers excessive or legally flawed.
Employment cases are heavily shaped by statutes and by the record made at trial. The appellate court does not hear new testimony about what happened at work. It reviews the record to decide whether the trial court applied the law correctly, and whether the evidence supports the result.
Wrongful termination and discrimination appeals
Discrimination and wrongful termination appeals often turn on the burden-shifting framework: whether the employee established a prima facie case, whether the employer offered a legitimate reason, and whether that reason was a pretext. Whether the trial court instructed the jury correctly on those steps is a question of law, reviewed de novo.
These appeals also frequently involve evidentiary issues — whether comparator evidence was admitted, whether an expert on workplace practices was qualified, and whether the court properly handled a mixed-motive instruction. Each of those issues has its own standard of review, and an experienced appellate attorney frames them separately.
Summary judgment appeals
Many employment cases never reach a jury. They are decided on summary judgment, where the court rules that no genuine dispute of material fact exists and one side is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. A summary judgment is reviewed de novo on appeal, which makes it one of the more promising grounds for an employment appeal.
The appellate court looks at the same evidence the trial court had, in the light most favorable to the party who lost below. If a reasonable jury could have found for the employee, the summary judgment should be reversed. That de novo review is why employment lawyers often advise an appeal even when the trial court’s reasoning seemed thorough.
Labor board and agency appeals
Not every employment dispute starts in court. Some go through agencies first — the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, a state fair employment agency, or the National Labor Relations Board. Decisions of the NLRB are reviewed by the federal courts of appeals, and the Board’s factual findings are reviewed for substantial evidence.
Agency appeals have their own deadlines and exhaustion requirements. A court will often refuse to hear an issue that was not raised before the agency, so the record made at the agency level matters as much as the record made at trial.
What to look for in an employment appeal attorney
Look for an attorney who handles employment appeals regularly and knows the statutes involved — Title VII, the ADA, the ADEA, the FMLA, and the equivalent state laws. Ask how many employment appeals they have briefed, whether they have handled summary judgment appeals, and whether they have published opinions.
Also ask about fees and fee-shifting. Many employment statutes allow the prevailing employee to recover attorney’s fees, including fees on appeal, and that can change the economics of the case. A good appellate attorney will explain the fee picture before you file.
Frequently Asked Questions About Employment Appeal Attorney
Yes. A summary judgment is appealable as a final judgment, and it is reviewed de novo on appeal — the appellate court looks at the evidence fresh, in the light most favorable to the party who lost below. That makes summary judgment one of the more promising grounds for an employment appeal.
In most courts the notice of appeal is due 30 days after entry of judgment, though the period varies by jurisdiction and by whether post-trial motions were filed. The deadline is jurisdictional. Contact an appellate attorney as soon as the judgment is entered.
Often, yes. Many employment statutes — including Title VII, the ADA, and state fair employment laws — allow a prevailing employee to recover attorney’s fees, including the fees incurred on appeal. An employer who wins generally cannot recover fees unless the claim was frivolous.
An EEOC dismissal usually comes with a right-to-sue letter, which gives you 90 days to file a lawsuit in federal court. The dismissal itself is not typically appealed — the lawsuit is the next step. If the agency made a legal error in handling your charge, your attorney can advise whether it matters to the case.
Find an Appellate Attorney in Your State
Browse certified appellate specialists and appeals lawyers in the states with the largest directories — or view all 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Browse appellate attorneys in all states → · Back to the homepage