What a workers’ comp appeal is
A workers’ compensation appeal challenges a decision of the workers’ compensation board or commission — a denial of benefits, a disability rating, a medical treatment dispute, or a settlement approval — for legal error. Workers’ comp is its own system, with its own judges, its own rules, and its own medical evidence, and appeals within it work differently from ordinary civil appeals.
The first appeal is usually inside the system itself: a petition for reconsideration to the board, asking it to review the workers’ compensation judge’s decision. Only after that can the case go to a regular court, usually on a writ.
The workers’ compensation board
Each state has its own workers’ compensation board or commission that administers claims and decides disputes. In California it is the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB); other states have similarly named bodies. The board reviews the workers’ compensation judge’s decision on reconsideration, and its decision can then be challenged in the court of appeal by a petition for a writ of review.
Because the board is a specialized body, its decisions are given deference by the courts. An attorney who practices regularly before the board knows how it treats the issues in your case and how to frame them.
Medical evidence: QME and AME reports
Most workers’ comp disputes turn on medical evidence. In California, the key evidence is usually a report from a Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME) or an Agreed Medical Evaluator (AME) — a physician who examines the worker and rates the disability. In other states, the treating physician’s reports and independent medical examinations play the same role.
The board gives great weight to the medical evaluator’s opinion, and a court reviewing the board’s decision will not reweigh the medical evidence. The winning appellate issues are usually legal — whether the board applied the right rating schedule, whether it followed its own procedures, or whether the evaluator’s opinion was substantial evidence at all.
Deadlines and reconsideration
Workers’ comp deadlines are short. In California, a petition for reconsideration must be filed within 20 days of service of the judge’s decision, and a petition for a writ of review in the Court of Appeal is due 45 days after the board’s decision. Other states have their own deadlines, and all of them are enforced strictly.
Because the reconsideration step is usually required before a court will hear the case, the clock starts running before the case ever leaves the board. Contact an attorney as soon as the decision arrives.
What to look for in a workers’ comp appeal attorney
Look for an attorney who handles workers’ compensation appeals specifically, not a general personal injury lawyer. Ask how many reconsideration petitions and writs they have filed, whether they know the board’s procedures, and whether they have handled cases involving your type of injury.
Also ask about fees. Workers’ comp fees are usually regulated by statute and are often a percentage of the benefits recovered, with the fee approved by the board. Get the arrangement in writing, and ask who pays the cost of the record if the appeal does not succeed.
Frequently Asked Questions About Workers' Compensation Appeal Attorney
It depends on the state. In California, a petition for reconsideration is due 20 days after service of the judge’s decision, and a writ petition in the Court of Appeal is due 45 days after the board’s decision. Other states have different deadlines, and all are enforced strictly.
Not directly. A QME or AME report is evidence, not a decision. You challenge it by arguing to the workers’ compensation judge — and then to the board on reconsideration — that the report is not substantial evidence, is based on an incorrect history, or is contradicted by other medical evidence.
The board reviews the judge’s decision for legal error and for whether the findings are supported by substantial evidence. A court reviewing the board applies the same substantial-evidence standard, which means the medical and factual findings are hard to overturn unless no reasonable evidence supports them.
Generally no. The medical evidence on appeal is the evidence that was before the judge and the board. A new evaluation usually requires a reopening of the case at the board level, and only if it is based on new and material evidence that could not have been presented earlier.
Find an Appellate Attorney in Your State
Browse certified appellate specialists and appeals lawyers in the states with the largest directories — or view all 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Browse appellate attorneys in all states → · Back to the homepage