What an extraordinary writ is
An extraordinary writ is a court order that compels a lower court or official to do something, or stops it from doing something, before the case is over. The most common writs are mandamus, which orders a court to act, and prohibition, which orders it not to act. Writs are extraordinary remedies — they are available only when there is no other adequate way to get relief.
Because writs bypass the ordinary appeal process, courts grant them sparingly. A writ petition must show that the lower court clearly abused its discretion, that the error cannot be fixed on appeal after a final judgment, and that the harm is immediate. An attorney who handles writs knows how high that bar is, and when a petition is worth filing.
Interlocutory appeals
Most orders made during a case cannot be appealed until the case ends. But there are exceptions. Some orders — such as orders granting or denying an injunction — are appealable immediately by statute. Others can be appealed if the trial court certifies the issue for interlocutory review, as under 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b) in federal court, and the court of appeals agrees to hear it.
Interlocutory appeals are discretionary on both ends: the trial court must certify the issue, and the appellate court must accept it. An experienced appellate attorney knows which orders qualify and how to frame the certification request.
Mandamus and prohibition
Mandamus is the most commonly sought writ. It asks a higher court to order a lower court to perform a duty it is required to perform — for example, to rule on a motion it has sat on for years, or to vacate an order it had no power to make. Prohibition is the mirror image: it asks the higher court to stop the lower court from doing something it has no power to do.
Both writs require a showing of a clear and indisputable right to relief, and that no other remedy exists. Courts emphasize that mandamus is not a substitute for an appeal, and they deny most petitions. The petitions that succeed are usually the ones where the lower court’s error is clear and the harm is irreparable.
The collateral order doctrine
The collateral order doctrine is another path to immediate review. Under it, an order can be appealed before final judgment if it conclusively determines a disputed question, resolves an important issue completely separate from the merits, and is effectively unreviewable on appeal from a final judgment. The classic examples are orders denying immunity and orders denying a motion to compel arbitration.
The doctrine is narrow, and courts apply it strictly. An attorney who knows the collateral order cases in your jurisdiction can tell you whether your order qualifies — and whether a writ petition would be a better vehicle.
What to look for in a writs attorney
Look for an attorney who handles writs and interlocutory appeals regularly, not a trial lawyer who files one in a panic. Ask how many writ petitions they have filed, how many were granted, and whether they have handled cases in the court that will decide yours.
Also ask for a candid assessment of the odds. Writs are granted rarely, and a good attorney will tell you when the better course is to wait for a final judgment and appeal in the ordinary way — and when the harm of waiting makes a writ the right call.
Frequently Asked Questions About Writ of Mandamus Attorney
When the ruling cannot be fixed on appeal after a final judgment, the harm is immediate, and the lower court clearly abused its discretion. Common examples are an order compelling disclosure of privileged material, an order refusing to rule, or an order that would moot the case. If the issue can wait for a final judgment, a writ is usually the wrong vehicle.
The collateral order doctrine allows an immediate appeal of an order that conclusively determines a disputed question, resolves an important issue completely separate from the merits, and is effectively unreviewable after a final judgment. Orders denying immunity and orders denying arbitration are the classic examples. The doctrine is applied narrowly.
Writ petitions have short, often jurisdictional deadlines that vary by court — in California, for example, a writ petition is generally due within 60 days of the order. Because the deadline runs from the order and is strictly enforced, contact an attorney as soon as the order is made.
Rarely. Courts grant a small fraction of writ petitions, because the standard is high and the remedy is extraordinary. The petitions that succeed are usually the ones where the lower court’s error is clear, the harm is irreparable, and there is no other adequate remedy.
Find an Appellate Attorney in Your State
Browse certified appellate specialists and appeals lawyers in the states with the largest directories — or view all 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Browse appellate attorneys in all states → · Back to the homepage